Skip to content
MukhyamantriMukhyamantri
BusinessMaharashtra

RBI wants the YES Bank bond order reopened, warns of a chill on future bank rescues

The Reserve Bank of India has filed a review petition against the Supreme Court's October 15 judgment that set aside the Rs 8,415-crore write-down of YES Bank's AT-1 bonds. The central bank argues the ruling misread the Basel III framework and could make investors wary of future rescue exercises.

· · 1 min read
RBI wants the YES Bank bond order reopened, warns of a chill on future bank rescues

Mumbai: The Reserve Bank of India has asked the Supreme Court to reconsider the judgment that set aside YES Bank's Rs 8,415-crore write-down of Additional Tier-1 bonds. The petition was filed on November 13 and appeared on the court's website on Monday.

On October 15, a bench of Justices Dipankar Datta and Augustine George Masih upheld the Bombay High Court, which had held in 2023 that the administrator appointed to run YES Bank had no power to write off AT-1 bonds not covered by the reconstruction scheme.

"The triumvirate of the RBI, the administrator, and YES Bank, in conducting the entire affair of dealing with the bonds worth more than Rs 8,415 crore, to put it mildly, is questionable," the court had observed.

The RBI's petition argues that the judgment contains errors apparent on the face of the record. It says the court did not adequately weigh the Basel III Master Circular, the loss-absorption mechanism built into these instruments, or the distinction between the pre-specified trigger and the point of non-viability trigger.

Restoring the bonds, the central bank contends, would dilute the capital infused into YES Bank during its 2020 reconstruction and weaken the loss-absorbing role of AT-1 instruments across the banking system. It has sought an open-court hearing and a stay on the judgment.

The dispute runs back to 2016 and 2017, when YES Bank issued two tranches of Basel III-compliant AT-1 bonds, of Rs 3,000 crore and Rs 5,415 crore. When the bank's finances deteriorated, the RBI moved to reconstruct it in March 2020. A moratorium was imposed on March 5, the board was superseded and an administrator appointed.

The draft reconstruction scheme provided for a permanent write-down of the bonds. That provision was dropped from the final scheme notified on March 13, 2020. A day later, on March 14, the administrator wrote down the entire Rs 8,415 crore.

Bondholders, represented by Axis Trustee Services, challenged the move in the Bombay High Court. YES Bank filed its own review petition on November 13 under Article 137 of the Constitution.

People familiar with the RBI's thinking said the worry is larger than one bank. If decisions taken during a rescue can be reopened five or six years later, investors may hesitate to put capital into the next lender that needs saving.